---
title: "IELTS Discussion Essay: Discuss Both Views Structure and Samples"
description: "IELTS discussion essay (discuss both views and give your opinion): a plan, where your opinion goes, and two sample answers AI-scored at band 6 and 8."
canonical: https://bandscorechecker.com/ielts-discussion-essay/
updated: 2026-11-20
---

# IELTS Discussion Essay (Discuss Both Views)

An IELTS discussion essay is the Writing Task 2 essay you write when the question ends with "Discuss both views and give your own opinion". Give the first view one body paragraph, give the second view another, and state your own opinion clearly in the introduction and the conclusion.

Check my discussion essay

## What a discuss both views question asks

The question describes two groups of people who disagree: "Some people think…, while others believe…". It then gives you two tasks, and both are marked under Task Response:

1. **Discuss both views.** Explain why each group thinks what it thinks. Give each view real reasons, even the one you reject.
2. **Give your own opinion.** Say which view you support, or where you stand between them, and why.

Your opinion can be one of the two views, or a position in between, such as "it depends on the student" or "both, but the first matters more". What it can't be is missing, or different in the introduction and the conclusion.

## Discussion essay structure

Both plans below fit 260 to 320 words, a safe length for the 250-word minimum in 40 minutes. Plan A is the most common; Plan B suits writers who want more room for their own view.

| Paragraph | Plan A: four paragraphs | Plan B: five paragraphs |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Introduction | Restate both views in your own words and give your opinion in one sentence. | The same. |
| Body 1 | The view you disagree with, explained fairly with a reason and an example. | The first view, explained fairly. |
| Body 2 | The view you support, explained and linked to why you find it stronger. | The second view, explained fairly. |
| Body 3 | Not needed. | Your own view: which side is more convincing and why, or the condition you add. |
| Conclusion | Repeat your opinion and the main reason. Add nothing new. | The same. |

Putting the view you support second lets the essay end on your side. If you partly agree with both, Plan B gives you a paragraph to say where you draw the line.

### Useful phrases

- **Opinion in the introduction:** While there are good arguments for…, I believe… / I side with those who…
- **Reporting a view:** Those who favour… argue that… / Supporters of… point out that… / The main argument for… is that…
- **Moving to your view:** In my view, the second argument is more convincing because… / I would agree with this only if…

Use these to help structure your ideas, not as memorised sentences. Phrases repeated word for word from a template don't raise your Lexical Resource score.

## IELTS discussion essay examples: band 6 and band 8

**Question:** Some people think young people should take a year off to travel or work before they start university, while others believe they should go to university straight after school. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

We wrote two answers to this discuss both views question, one weaker and one stronger, and scored each once with our AI checker on 2026-11-20. The bands are AI estimates, not examiner marks ([how accurate the checker is](https://bandscorechecker.com/ielts-writing-checker-accuracy/)).

### Band 6 answer (260 words)

Nowadays many students finish high school and they have to decide what to do next. Some people think it is good to take a gap year for travel or work, but other people think students should go to university immediately. In this essay I will discuss both side and give my opinion.

On the one hand, a gap year have many benefits. Young people can travel to other countries and learn about different culture. They can also work and earn some money, so they do not need to borrow so much money for university. For example, my cousin worked in a cafe for one year and he become more mature and responsible. When he started university he know what he want to study.

On the other hand, some people believe students should go to university directly. The main reason is that they will not forget what they learned in school. If they stop studying for one year, maybe it is difficult to start again. Also, travelling is very expensive and many family can not afford it. Some students also become lazy during the gap year and they do not want to go back to study anymore.

In my opinion, both opinions have advantages. I think a gap year is good for some students but not for everyone. Students who already know what they want to study should go to university straight away, and the students who are not sure can take a gap year.

In conclusion, there are good points on both sides and every student should decide by themself.

| Criterion | Band | Checker's comment |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Task Response | **6.5** | The essay answers all parts of the question with a clear position, but some ideas lack development and support. |
| Coherence and Cohesion | **7** | The essay is well organized and easy to follow, with appropriate paragraphing and a range of cohesive devices. |
| Lexical Resource | **6** | Vocabulary is sufficient for the task, but there are noticeable errors in word choice and form. |
| Grammatical Range and Accuracy | **6** | Grammar shows a mix of structures but with frequent errors that sometimes affect clarity. |
| Overall | **6** | Average of the four, rounded down to a half band. |

#### What held it back

- Frequent subject-verb agreement errors (e.g., 'a gap year have', 'he know').
- Inconsistent verb tense usage.
- Limited range of vocabulary with some word form errors.

#### Corrections the checker made

- a gap year have many benefits → **a gap year has many benefits**
Subject-verb agreement: 'a gap year' is singular, so the verb should be 'has'.
- learn about different culture → **learn about different cultures**
Plural form needed after 'different'.
- he become more mature → **he became more mature**
Past tense needed for a completed action.

### Band 8 answer (311 words)

Whether school leavers should spend a year travelling or working before university, or move on to higher education immediately, is a question many families now face. While there are sound arguments for going straight to university, I believe a well-planned gap year benefits most young people.

Those who favour continuing without a break argue that momentum matters. Study habits built over twelve years of school can fade quickly, and a student who has spent months away from books may struggle with the first set of university exams. There is also a financial argument: a year's delay means a year less of full-time earnings later in life, and for families on modest incomes, a year of travel is simply out of reach.

Supporters of a gap year, however, point out that many eighteen-year-olds choose a degree with little idea of what it involves. A year spent working in an office, a hospital or a shop gives them a realistic picture of different careers, so they are less likely to drop out or change courses later, which is itself costly. A job also teaches punctuality and responsibility in a way that school rarely does, and travelling on a tight budget forces young people to solve problems without their parents' help.

In my view, the second argument is more convincing, provided the year has a clear purpose. A gap year need not be an expensive trip abroad; working locally and saving money towards tuition fees gives the same maturity at no cost. The risk of losing study habits is real, but it can be reduced by setting a fixed university start date before the year begins.

In conclusion, although going directly to university keeps students in the habit of studying, I believe a structured year of work or travel helps most young people choose their course more wisely and arrive at university better prepared.

| Criterion | Band | Checker's comment |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Task Response | **8** | The essay fully addresses all parts of the question, presents a clear position, and develops ideas with relevant support. Only minor lapses in depth prevent a 9. |
| Coherence and Cohesion | **8** | The essay is very well organised with logical sequencing and appropriate use of cohesive devices. Paragraphing is effective. |
| Lexical Resource | **8** | The essay demonstrates a wide vocabulary used with precision and naturalness. There are only rare minor slips. |
| Grammatical Range and Accuracy | **8** | The essay shows a wide range of grammatical structures used accurately. Errors are rare and do not impede communication. |
| Overall | **8** | Average of the four, rounded down to a half band. |

#### What held it back

- The counterargument could be developed slightly more to show deeper critical thinking.
- Minor repetition of 'year' could be avoided with synonyms.
- A few phrases could be made more concise or precise.

At this level the checker's suggestions were small wording choices, such as "one less year" instead of "a year less", minor style preferences rather than errors, so we haven't listed them.

Answer this question yourself and check it

## What lifts the band 6 answer to band 8

Both answers follow the right plan: one paragraph for each view and an opinion near the end. The checker gave the band 6 answer 7 for Coherence and Cohesion, so the gap is mostly in how far each idea goes and in accuracy.

- **Each view is explained, not listed.** The band 6 answer gives the "go straight to university" side three quick points in a row (forgetting what you learned, the cost of travel, becoming lazy). The band 8 answer takes two of them and says why they matter: study habits "can fade quickly", and "for families on modest incomes, a year of travel is simply out of reach". The checker's Task Response comment on the band 6 answer was that "some ideas lack development and support" (6.5 against 8).
- **An opinion with a reason.** The checker found a clear position in both answers. The band 6 answer's view, a gap year for students who are unsure and straight to university for those who know what to study, comes with no reason. The band 8 answer chooses a side, adds a condition ("provided the year has a clear purpose") and answers the other side's strongest point: a fixed start date reduces the risk of losing study habits.
- **Accurate grammar.** Errors such as "a gap year have", "he become" and "he know" left the band 6 answer with Grammar 6. The band 8 answer has almost no errors (Grammar 8).
- **Precise vocabulary.** Where the band 6 answer uses "students finish high school" and "go to university directly", with slips such as "learn about different culture", the band 8 answer uses "school leavers", "momentum" and "tuition fees": Lexical Resource 6 against 8.

For three more answers to a discuss both views question, at band 5.5, 7.5 and 8, see our [Task 2 sample answers](https://bandscorechecker.com/ielts-writing-task-2-sample-answers/#parks).

## Mistakes that cost marks in discussion essays

- **No opinion.** Discussing both views and stopping there answers only half the question.
- **"Both sides have good points" as the opinion.** That restates the question. Say which side matters more, or under what condition each one is right.
- **An opinion that changes.** Supporting one side in the introduction and the other in the conclusion is an unclear position, which costs Task Response marks.
- **A weak paragraph for the other side.** Two lines on the view you reject doesn't discuss it. Give it a reason and an example, as you would your own.
- **Writing an opinion essay instead.** Spending the whole essay on your own side leaves the other view undiscussed. For the question that asks only how far you agree, see our [opinion essay guide](https://bandscorechecker.com/ielts-opinion-essay/).
- **Lists instead of explanations.** Three points in three short sentences score lower than two points, each with a reason or an example.

## Discuss both views essay topics to practise

These are original practice questions in the style of the test. Tap one to put it in the checker, write for 40 minutes, then check your essay.

1. Education Some people think children should start learning a foreign language at primary school, while others believe it is better to begin at secondary school. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
2. Technology Some people believe online courses will soon replace traditional classrooms, while others think face-to-face teaching will always be necessary. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
3. Work Some people think it is better to stay in one job for many years, while others believe changing jobs often is the best way to build a career. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
4. Environment Some people think private cars should be banned from city centres, while others believe this would harm local businesses. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
5. Health Some people believe the government should tax sugary drinks to improve public health, while others think people should be free to choose what they eat and drink. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
6. Society Some people think older people should live with their adult children, while others believe they are better off in care homes. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
7. Media Some people think news should be free for everyone online, while others believe readers should pay for good journalism. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
8. Crime Some people believe that more police on the streets is the best way to reduce crime, while others think education and job opportunities matter more. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
9. Sport Some people think every child should have to play team sports at school, while others believe children should be free to choose their own activities. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

For eight more, see the [discussion questions](https://bandscorechecker.com/ielts-writing-task-2-questions/#discussion) in our Task 2 question bank, and for ideas on the most common topics, its [ideas and vocabulary by topic](https://bandscorechecker.com/ielts-writing-task-2-questions/#ideas).

## What the checker tells you about your essay

Paste the question along with your essay. Task Response is then scored against that exact question, so the comment can tell you whether you covered both views and gave a clear opinion. For what the next band asks of you, see the [band descriptors, explained](https://bandscorechecker.com/ielts-writing-band-descriptors/).

### Free

- Overall band and all four criterion bands
- Why each band was given
- The three problems costing you the most marks
- Your 3 most serious mistakes corrected, with the reason for each
- Explanations in English or 20 other languages, such as Vietnamese, Bengali and Hindi
- 1 check a day, or 2 a day with a free account
- With a free account: your history and a progress chart

### Full feedback

- Everything in Free
- Every correction, sentence by sentence, with reasons
- Your essay rewritten at band 8, keeping your ideas
- Vocabulary upgrades and paragraph-by-paragraph comments
- Up to 30 checks a day

[See plans from $29.99 a year](https://bandscorechecker.com/pricing/)

## Questions

### What is a discussion essay in IELTS?

It is the Task 2 question that describes two opposing views and usually ends with "Discuss both views and give your own opinion." You explain each view in its own paragraph and say which one you support, or where you stand between them.

### Do I have to give my opinion in a discuss both views essay?

Yes. The question asks for two things, both views and your opinion, and leaving out your opinion means part of the question is unanswered. Say it in the introduction and again in the conclusion.

### Where should I put my opinion in a discussion essay?

State it in the introduction, keep it the same in the conclusion, and, if you like, show it in the paragraph about the view you support. Some writers add a short paragraph of their own view before the conclusion, as the band 8 sample above does; either way the reader should never have to guess where you stand.

### Can I agree with both views?

You can partly agree with each, but you still need a clear overall position, such as "both have a point, but the first matters more because…" or "it depends on the student". "Both sides have good points" with no reason is not a position.

### What is the difference between a discussion essay and an opinion essay?

An opinion essay gives a single statement and asks how far you agree, so you can spend the whole essay on your own side. A discussion essay gives two views and asks you to explain both fairly before giving your own. See our [IELTS opinion essay guide](https://bandscorechecker.com/ielts-opinion-essay/) for the other type.

### Can I check my discussion essay for free?

Yes: 1 check a day without signing up, or 2 a day with a free account, with a band for every criterion and the 3 most serious corrections. Every other correction and a band 8 rewrite come with a [paid plan](https://bandscorechecker.com/pricing/).

---

Independent practice tool. Not affiliated with, approved or endorsed by IELTS, the British Council, IDP or Cambridge University Press & Assessment. IELTS is a registered trademark of its owners. Scores are AI estimates, not official results.
